Double Take! Which Cover Did It Better?

So,  I originally was going to post a review today, but the other day, I was searching for interesting ebooks on Amazon, and I came across a cover that looked eerily familiar. Here was the first cover I found:

And then I thought, wow. How familiar. So, I did some searching around, and remembered that this book also had that same style:

De Ja Vu? Which cover do you think won the better cover contest?